Athée Canadien
Is Atheism Enough?
By John
Brent recently commented on the fact that more and more people are identifying themselves primarily by their non-belief. I do think this is a better situation than when atheists are scared to tell people their worldview. However, I don’t think just not believing in god warrants a person any amount of respect, at least from myself. People who are born into an atheist family and don’t want to or care to delve into the rational underpinning of atheism, I think, deserve far less respect than religious people who question their faith and arrive at their beliefs after extensive intellectual exploration.
Being an atheist also does not automatically make someone a good person. Take China for example. I remember a few years back when Dr. Paul Kurtz spoke very fondly of the high amount of atheism in China, that it is an enlightened country that values scientific values and critical thinking. This is unfortunately far from the truth. Although the communist regime decried religion through propaganda, most Chinese people are incredibly superstitious, petty, selfish, greedy, xenophobic, and all-round nasty. I can’t really blame them – entire generations of Chinese were raised venerating the cult of the communist regime, and when they realized that it is rotten to the core, all they had left to believe in was money. Morality and ethics be damned, as long as they can live long and prosper.
Even the most educated city Chinese are very superstitious. My cousin living in Shanghai, one of the biggest and richest cities in China, to give a personal example, was exorcised at the request of her mother by a Daoist nun because she wasn’t doing well in school. Buddhist temples in China get so much donation by people seeking better fortune and wealth, that there is a saying: if you want a quick way to get rich, shave your head and become a monk for five years. I’m not even going to go into traditional Chinese medicine and other witchcraft-like beliefs that permeate the entire country and replace Western, evidence-based medicine.
China, I think, is the perfect example of why atheism alone really isn’t enough. What matters should be the intellectual path one takes to get to being an atheist, and what happens after. What is important for me above all is whether or not you’re a good person who tries to make the world a better place. This is why atheists need to rise above mere non-belief, and where the ethical philosophies of secular humanism is sorely needed.
On a side note, I will be flying to China in a couple of hours for a 3-week vacation and family visits, and will surely discover many new social problems to complain about after I get back :P
| Print article | This entry was posted by John on August 15, 2010 at 8:46 am, and is filed under Atheism, Critical Thinking, Ethics, Secular Humanism, Skepticism. Follow any responses to this post through RSS 2.0. Both comments and pings are currently closed. |
Comments are closed.

about 1 year ago
I think it is better not to generalize that all chinese people are as John described them. But I have an issue with this idea that atheism has content and its content is not enough. Atheism has no content, just like the disbelief in astrology and ghosts and wizards – has no context. Secular Humanism is a philosophy and context and that is why, one could make a good argument that secular humanism sounds better than atheism – but not all atheists are secular humanists.
about 1 year ago
You’ve missed the point.
about 1 year ago
Yes, unfortunately, those people are atheists for all the wrong reasons. Augh.
Not a bad idea.
about 1 year ago
As an atheist who came to be one after a pastorate of 20 years for a fundamentalist christian cult, I disagree.
I tend to admire atheists, especially in the US, because to remain atheist, they had to develop their own thoughts and decide to remain. There are christians on every corner trying to convert you.
And the generalizations of Chinese remind me of similar generalizations I experienced in the South, only it was African-Americans, not Chinese. Generalizations are always ugly…. oh wait… that was a generalization!
One thing I have noticed since becoming an atheist is a large number of former believers who have become fundamentalist atheists. They have the same exact perspective as christian fundamentalists, but just switched sides. They are right, they are sure they are right, and they won’t let anyone tell them they aren’t right.
In retrospect, I realize I was dead wrong for most of my life. I may be just as wrong now, but unless evidence convinces me… this is what I believe.
about 1 year ago
If you grew up thinking of religion as Judaism, Christianity, and Islam, then any sort of irrationality that doesn’t look similar to those religions will look secular to you.
about 1 year ago
On a related note, here’s a really good atheist store I found. Well, primarily atheist and science stuff…
Aristotle’s Muse
Maybe wearing an atheist T-shirt won’t change the world, but then again, maybe it could.